Canon would refer to the body of works related to a particular subject and considered proper history and continuity to series. The Doom series may contain more than one canon based on storylines of various reboot universes.
See also Timeline.
In case of Doom there are very few official comments that relate to canon or discuss canon directly. Sometimes official positions are contradictory or changes over time (or retcons are made).
As such there are a number of fan theories as to what comprises canon or what is not canon these can only be considered Fanon as their is very little as far as confirmation on what is canon.
In addition the Doom series has received a number of spinoffs and reboots throughout its life as well as tie ins.
Each reboot could be considered separate canons or alternate universes as part of a multiverse (Quake Arena backstory for example, Arena Eternal outside time and space, with heroes from various “alternate universes”).
Tom Hall and John Romero have confirmed that several ID series are in fact connected. Doom Marine (from Doom/Ultimate Doom) is a Blazkowicz descended from Commander Keen, and William J. Blazkowicz before him (this does not apply to the MachineGames reboot universe however which follows its own universe with an alternate history for B.J. and a different family tree). This is also mentioned in Wolfenstein/Doom RPG series as well. See ID multiverse timeline.
In both Doom RPG website and Doom 3 boxset the hero for most of the games is alluded to be the same hero in Doom 1-3 (and the RPG series). However, the exact order of the series is not entirely clear. With some interpretations placing Doom 3 as a sequel after first two games, and others as a prequel. A number of sources would support the idea that original Doom series takes place almost a century before Doom 3.
However Doom II’s marine may or may not be the same character or a separate character from the Doom I character depending on different manuals and websites. His backstory differs from that of the original Doom character in that he fought on UAC Mars Base and escaped in a drop ship (mirroring events of Doom 3). Whereas as original Doom character fought in Phobos and Mars and in both original Doom and Ultimate Doom reaches earth via transporter gateways. Both Doom RPG website and Doom 3 BFG Edition try to establish that its the same Marine in all the games (however this would ignore certain details from other manuals or the games themselves, or at least make things in the timeline far more convoluted, or at least in an unknown order). Doom 3 BFG Edition's manual also goes as far to include Lost Mission and Resurrection of Evil in that claim (which is unlikely considering that in-game clearly indicates they are seperate Marines with different ID numbers, and in case of Doom 3 and Lost Episodes occur concurrently with each other).
Quake Champions brings back Doom (Quake III Arena), now listed as Doom Slayer, and mentions his pet Daisy confirming a link between Doom 2016 and Doom 1. Doom Slayer also comes with his uniforms from Doom 2016 (Praetor Suit), Doom Classic (Doomguy), Quake Arena (Arena), and Doom 3 (Doom Marine), and biography details that links all the games together.
The game also brings new MachineGames William Blazkowicz from his “universe” to the Arena Eternal (the place outside of time and space).
The Fanon tends to argue against the veracity of some of these sources, assigning different levels of theorized canonicity to the various references. But for most part ID’s internal position is not known.
Levels of Canon
- Developer Commentary: Occasional discussions on what is canon in developers minds, but it is rarely touched upon.
- Games: These are generally considered to be primary canon, or may comprise more than one canon (Master Levels really has no story (or unused 'fanfic' backgrounds for when the levels were originally intended to be fan wads)).
- Manuals: Generally considered canon, but may contain contradictory materials in later releases of the games (BFG Edition Manual for example). Not all the manuals agree with each other, sometimes being replaced with new manuals with alternate information in later releases of games.
- Websites: These come and go, and are not often maintained and erased from the internet after a few years. Information is usually quite official, but only a few broken backups may remain.
- Id Multiverse/Universe: This is comprised of crossover material and confirmed 'shared universe/multiverse' of other iD games. These are confirmed by current and former iD developers, and tied into some of the games such as Quake Champions.
- Novels: These are generally not considered canon, and tell an alternate version of the games they are based on, with directly conflicting details, or character names. Doom and Doom II and spinoff novels in particular deviate much from the game's official storylines. However, the Doom 3 novels mirrors Doom 3 (but many of the characters are treated differently). Certain details and characters from the two books have been incorporated and influenced material in other games such as Doom RPG (but not necessarily adapted directly).
- Movie/Novelization: This canonicity of this source is unknown. On one hand it takes place in an era largely not covered in other sources (Late 2020s-2050, see Film timeline somewhat similar to the Doom Timeline of the classic games), and thus could be seen as a prequel (to Doom 3, and taking place after original Doom series and Final Doom). On the other hand, its sort of a generic story, highly influenced by Doom 3's story. Almost a retelling without a proper demonic invasion (just humans mutating into monstrous creatures). But the novel might hint at very early invasions in ancient Mar's history.
- Wolfenstein, Commander Keen, and Doom are connected according to Tom Hall.
- Wolfenstein RPG and Doom RPGs include crossover material with a number of ID series and each other. Even as much as mentioning Orcs & Elves series.
- Doom II RPG and Doom Resurrection have references to each other. The character Sam appears in Doom Resurrection until it is destroyed saving the player character's life, and its remains are rediscovered in Doom II RPG showing its final outcome.
- There are some crossover material between Doom, Doom 3, Doom (2016) and Quake Arena III, Quake Champions. The latter also has crossover with MachineGames Wolfenstein universe. Quake Champions is said to be a prequel to Quake Arena which also has version of Doom Marine from another era.
- Doom RPG and Doom 3 novels share details and backstory. Ian Kelliher, and the Doom RPG website claims that the hero is the same hero from Doom I, II, and Doom III. Deimos is already missing seemingly a nod to the original Doom.
- The backstory in Doom II manual is similar to the plot of Doom 3, with lone space marine saving Mars Base. Doom RPG also has a similar plot. The only difference is when these times take 'chronologically' (Doom 2 is likely roughly 21st century, and Doom 3/RPG both take place in the 22nd).
- The protagonist of the Doom 3 novels shares the same last name as the main character in Quake II (although there is no known direct connection between the two).
- There are crossover elements in R.A.G.E. such as Mixom corporation. However the game is likely in a parallel universe where earth asteroid hit earth on August 23, 2029, and main character wakes up 108 years later in 2135 which is only a few years before Doom 3/4 which are each set roughly in 2145-2149. Based on what is known about earth in Doom series its unlikely its as bad off as it was in Rage 10-20 years before.
- Doom 2016 and Doom 3 are likely in alternate earth universes, although the same Marine apparently travelled through Worlds and Time to both according to Quake Champions, and info in Doom 2016.
- A comic in Quake for Saturn included and adventure following Quake Marines Dank and Scud run into the Doom Marine during their adventures. Assuming that Quake took place between 2008 and 2108, he'd either have had to have time travelled, interdimensional traveled, or the date would have to be set closer to the original Doom Timeline in the early 2020s.
- Although Doom 3 is said to be in same universe as Doom I and II (and Doom RPG) it is unknown if it is a prequel or a sequel in some fashion. Quake Champions is not clear, but just includes elements of the story in the back information for Doom Slayer. The backstory for the Marine/Slayer is similar to manual prologue in Doom 1, however assuming that Doom took place in early 21st century (as per SNES and novels), then Doom 3 would have to occur in the far future (almost 120 years later) which would have problems with Doom 64 (unless Doom 64 was after Doom 3 and Doom RPG), but this would require for Doom Marine to have gone into stasis at some point on Earth most likely, before returning Mars. Doom 64 is implied in Doom 2016 and even more strongly in Quake Champions to be events that lead up to 2016 game.
- Keel in Quake Champions appears to be based on Revenants.
- The UAC is mentioned ins ome of Quake 4's background. According to Quake IV: The "Armstrong" was an Orbital Space Station in low orbit around the Earth. During the Strogg invasion of Earth, it was used by the U.A.C. to study and store creatures and weapons developed on Mars. When the Strogg invaded Earth, the station had been turned into an Orbital Defense Platform, but it was ultimately taken down by the Strogg. During this incident, Kane found an old U.A.C. weapon which he used to survive. He turned out to be the only survivor of this attack, but The United Nations kept him quiet about this incident, leading to rumors that the weapon wasn't all he had found. As Quake II/IV takes place in 21st century and thus likely overlaps the orignal Doom Timeline, and there are no direct references to Strogg invasions in any Doom related materials its possible that Quake II/IV universe is also in a seperate earth of the iD multiverse.
- A level in a Wolfenstein 3D expansion has B.J. traveling to the future into a UAC base in an unknown location. In Spear of Destiny: Mission 3: Ultimate Challenge, Hitler has found a way via the occult to see into the future and even travel there, and he's stealing technology in order to give the Nazis and advantage over the Allies. At one point B.J. Blazcowicz is transported to the future into a UAC base where he sees UAC boxes, and Doom computer monitors showing the sun. Like in Doom its been invaded by a Demonic force (Devil Incarnate).
- All the collectable dolls/action figures in Doom 2016 are based on other ID franchise and classic Doom games.
- Rage has a secret teleporter leading to the first room of E1M1: Hangar. There, the player can pick up a Doom Marine Bobblehead. There are also similar secret areas calling back to Wolfenstein 3D and Quake.
- Some Fanon does not accept developer comments, partly due to the fact that developers come and go, and varies per game. Many of the original developers on Doom to Doom II no longer work at ID software. And the developers of Doom 3 and Doom 2016 for example are different developers and sometimes different companies outside of ID software. Currently Bethesda owns the franchise and they have said little confirming or denying the status of canon or canons of the series.
- Some Fanon considers the Doom Slayer in Doom (2016) to follow the interdimensional adventures of the original classic Doom Marine after Doom 64 in a new parallel earth (as confirmed in Quake Champions and his ties to "Daisy"), however they also consider Doom 3 to be in a seperate 'canon'/'alternate universe' from the other two, or at least Doom 3 Marine being a different individual than the one from the original series, even it from the same timeline. Quake Champions does contain information about Doom 3 Marine in the armor bios, but offers no explanation as to how it fits chronologically with the Classic Marine, Arena Marine (Doom), or Doom Slayer (some fans point out that Quake Champions is about pulling characters from parallel dimensions that the skins could simply be "parallel universe' version of Doom Slayer's character from several different Earth universes). The rabbit's foot and its description however is standard gear for the basic Doom Slayer character skin (and specifically refers back to the Doom Slayer in it's description), and Doom Slayer himself is pulled From Doom (2016) including his bio from that game. His other standard accessor gear is the backpack he keeps the mini versions of himself in (referencing all the dolls collected in the Doom 2016).
- The introduction of the character in Doom II manual discusses a Mars invasion in the UAC Mars Base (sort of a precursor to the plot of Doom 3 and Doom RPG), and tells of a completely different set of events than occur in both the original Doom or Ultimate Doom endings which took place on Phobos and Deimos instead. Some Fanon believe this to mean that the marines in Doom 1 and Doom 2 are completely different individuals who reached Earth by different means (Mars hero by drop ship, and the Phobos/Deimos marine by teleportation).
- According to the Doom 64 manual it mentions “planetary” twice and “space installation” when discussing previous events. Some Fanon believes this may be a reference Phobos/Deimos invasion, while others believe it could be a reference to the Doom (character)sn't specify which.). Doom II introduced the Mars installation itself had also been saved from a demonic invasion (the base itself was also mentioned in the backstory for the original Doom).
- The nature of canon or canons is unknown, with hints at possibilities of there being a single timeline (and sometimes single character) for at least much of the material according to some interpretations (BFG Edition, and Doom RPG website), or a single canon including a doom multiverse with multiple parallel earths being invaded by the same Hell dimension as implied by Quake Champions and Doom 2016 (which could make Quake Arena/Champions events (see Doom (character)), the classic Doom universe, Doom 3 universe, Doom RPG universe, and Doom/Doom Eternal universe, each seperate but connected through Hell. Doom Slayer according to quake is directly connected to the oriignal Doom Marine from Doom/Ultimate Doom, but appears to have been discovered in Hell by explorers from yet another parallel Earth universe, one in which actively worships Demons). But alternatively each iteration could represent their own seperate canons, divided into groupings including Classic Doom series, Doom 3 series, Doom RPG series, and Doom 2016 series (in which any 'nods' between each game would only be seen as 'Easter eggs' at the most).
- Some Fanon prefers to think of 'current' iteration as 'canon' and previous series Classic Doom series, or Doom 3 series, or Doom RPG series as non-canon (assuming they don't also acknowledge the idea that Doom Slayer is the Doom 1 Marine).
- Some Fanon (depending on individuals) do not accept "extra/additional/add-on" materials such as Maximum Doom, Master Levels, Final Doom, Lost Episode, Doom 64, Thy Flesh Consumed (it has a second confusing ending in conflict with Doom's original ending, as both more less end with the Marine ending up on earth from Hell discovering his Dead Daisy), No Rest For the Living, or console ports/adaptations (such as PSX/Saturn/GBA/SNES) as canon. In one sense at least Master Levels was not stand alone and is largely a bunch of level packs put together for ID under contract (many of which do not have stories, some stories that are included are not even set in the Doom Universe at all (but try to tell some kind of non-Doom backstory), or simply the stories are not very good/just fan fic (intended for when the levels were going to be released for free on the internet) rife with spelling errors and lack of editing, and not even discussed in the manual). Maximum Doom is just a completely random compilation of stuff taken from the internet without much oversight.
- A number of commercial campaigns such as The_Lost_Episodes_of_Doom are simply third-party with no official ID involvement or licensing... Thus should not be considered 'canon' at all.
- ↑ https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/arstechnica.com/gaming/2018/01/id-software-co-founders-confirm-that-its-biggest-games-heroes-are-all-related/%3famp=1
- ↑ https://www.resetera.com/threads/keen-blazkowicz-and-doomguy-are-all-related-tom-hall-confirms.19853/
- ↑ "You, the tough Marine, are returning to a space installation you once saved from these vile beasts. Unfortunately you weren't as thorough as you thought, and their carcasses were resurrected."