Talk:Sean's Doom Info

Could this be considered spam?

Does the Doom Wiki have an "external links" page anywhere?


 * The answer to the second question is no. Every "important" web site is supposed to have its own article.  Category:Websites contains the articles that have been started so far, and includes some other wikis as you can see.  Currently we don't have clear-cut criteria for deciding which sites should be documented (this is something that was discussed a while ago, but I don't think anybody reads it before adding new articles), so this page isn't necessarily spam.  It certainly looks more like a user profile than part of the encyclopedia, however.  The site in question has only existed for about a week, so I also wonder how prominent it could be within the Doom community at large.    Ryan W 11:33, 12 June 2009 (UTC)

Deletion
I copied the content from this page to Yoshielectronfan761's user page, and now I'm nominating this article for deletion. My rationale for the deletion is:
 * It is pretty obvious that the user's own wiki cannot be considered notable by any means of measurement at this point - it doesn't even have any content yet.
 * The user's WAD project is in-progress, and we only document released projects.
 * The user's YouTube videos have very few views, and I wouldn't therefore consider the YouTube account notable enough for its own article. If we are going to link to it on this wiki outside Yoshielectronfan761's user page, Fan-made Doom movies is probably the correct medium (although I don't really see a reason for that either).

So overall, a strong delete vote from me. -- Janizdreg 03:40, 14 June 2009 (UTC)